This started of as a response to the comments in this and grew out of control.
Though I have family that work in the construction trade, I know no one who has ever had a serious fall from a ladder. Most everyone I know washes every day (as far as I can tell) and yet I don’t know anyone who has drowned in a bathtub. I know of several near-misses, but I don’t know anyone who has been killed by a firearm, either accidentally or deliberately.
The funny thing about social policy is that there’s only so far you can push before stuff starts popping out in strange places.
There’s not much you can reasonably do about ladder falls, except maybe occasionally remind people to ‘get a buddy to hold the damn thing for you’. The bulk of ‘firearm deaths’ (the phrase carefully chosen so the careless reader thinks only homicides are involved) in the US are caused by suicide, and you’re either going to do that or your not. One can debate gun policy till you’re blue in the face, but there seems to be an inverse relationship between the ability and willingness of homeowners to use weapons and the amount of property crime one gets in society. I have no serious policy suggestions for stopping bathtub drownings, though if one generalizes to water accidents, we could cut that number in half by banning booze. And we know how that worked out.
Most accidents are caused either by dumbasses or people acting like dumbasses, and I’m afraid there’s very little solving that.
9/11? I won’t bore you with the details, except to note that I knew 3 people there, through 0 or 1 levels of indirection, and two of them are dead. I work in the financial sector so you could claim that it’s not too surprising; or perhaps it’s just too crass of me to mention them at all, to make my case on somebody’s immolated body. Ok, fair enough.
You know anyone retired or retiring in the last three years. Odds are, they were affected by 9/11. Do you know anyone working in tourism? I do. They were screwed by 9/11. Do you anyone who works in an airline? I do: they were screwed by 9/11. Do you know anyone in New York? They have no neutral opinions about 9/11, I’m sure. Do you know anyone in the military? In the reserves? Their life has been made a lot more interesting in the last few years, don’t you think especially, though not exclusively, if they’re Americans. Do you know anyone self-employed? I was; now I’m not. Do you know any Jews? Of course you do, they all didn’t show up to work at the WTC on the morning of the 11th, ha ha ha, just kidding (though the ones making that claim aren’t).
Look, shit happens: every single person who ever lived knows this deep in their bones. Life often ends too early, in tragedy or in farce, fodder for drinking stories or cautionary tales. However, 9/11 wasn’t an accident: 9/11 was done to us.
And if there’s one thing I expect from my government, it’s to do everything in its power to stop it from happening to us again. That’s why it’s there.
On September 12, I listened to several hours of Gwyn Dyer (with Rex Murphy) on CBC and he was insightful and brilliant. I guess it got stale for him quickly: he got over it, what’s the matter with the rest of us? It’s so ’01; wake up man, people are drowning in bathtubs! Or perhaps it’s all just upside now, what with all the punditry jobs and so forth.