BlogMatrix
 

More on Mailing Lists and Usenet Newsgroups

edit David Janes 2004-05-15 18:12 UTC 2 comments  ·

I can't leave it at that. Here's the problem with Usenet, from an syndication/blog reader perspective:

  • Individual posts are "firehose". They just keep coming and coming.
  • Topics (i.e. collections of related posts) are almost as bad.
  • Topics wander off topic (usually degenerating to personal insults and Godwin's law type verifiers).
  • Spam, spam, spam.
  • Only a very small percentage of posts/topics will even marginally interest you, uinless you're a real sucker for punishment.
  • Spam, spam, spam.

Generally, we can sum this up by saying this is the "needle in the haystack" problem. How much time are you, the reader, willing to spending tossing straw to find that one needle of information that might be of interest. I think this problem is crackable, but I don't think just feeds of posts or topics will solve the problem. Threading information in the post will, if the readers can take advantage of it.

Comment #1Pete

2004-05-15 21:14:30
Personally I'm more interested in listserve "feeds" -- but the other problem that came to mind with newsgroups is that, often times, simple filters probably wouldn't help much. A person could probably work up a complex set of them that would help, but from my recent forays into newsgroups it seems that the signal to noise ratio is VERY low.

Comment #2David

2004-05-15 22:46:14
Yes, Listserv feeds -- or more, generally speaking, conversion of POP3 mailboxes.

Usenet has a lot of junk, no doubt. I think it's doable -- especially with some support on the reader side for filtering.